Saturday, February 19, 2011

Dissertation: 4.0 Alternative to be Truth to Material- A Conscious of Admiring Local Raw Material

Diving to the bottom of the subject, the intention of introducing the concept is to criticize the innovating Eco-friendly finishing product do not help the environment, but become another marketing method for those finishing product.  This chapter will be introducing an alternative of the concept – truth to material. Previous chapter have shown the advantages and the beauty of applying truth to material’s concept in architecture, an idea to go beyond this concept is not merely appreciating the origin beauty of the construction material but appreciating the local raw material too. Therefore, the selling point of the alternative is using local raw material while applying truth to material concept in architecture field. This alternative not only helps the environment, it bring out the architecture regionalism too.

4.1 How this Alternative Help on Environmental Problems.
Compare to worshiping the imported raw material, using local raw material for architecture construction can reduce the transportation cost and energy wasted. In most of the localities, natural world has given us with some materials to build with, and these material require little processing or transportation. No doubt, transportation plays a major role in the environmental issue.
In general, the biggest contributors to the carbon footprints of individuals in industrialized nations are transportation and household electricity use.” (Nodvin, 2010)
Emissions of green house gases cause global warming; and CO2 is the major gas. Transport is one of the main contributors of the CO2 gases. Reducing or avoiding the uses of imported raw material in architecture field can reduce a big amount of transportation used.

4.2 Case Study of Architecture Staying True to Local Material
Buildings constructed with local material can reflect the regionalism of the architecture is not a new topic. It can be shown from most of the vernacular architecture.
The best representative of vernacular architecture constructed with local material nothing else is worthy except traditional Malay Houses, which are the timber house designed to suit the tropical climate. For an example, Long Roofed House (Fig. 18) located in Perlis, Malaysia, so-called Rumah Perlis in Malay is mostly constructed with local wood, such as Chengal wood and Damar Laut wood. ( K.I Pengurusan Holdings Sdn Bhd, 2011) Chengal is referring to Neobalanocarus Heimii and Damar Laut is referring to Shorea Maxwelliana, both are the wood endemic to Malay Peninsula. (Rimbun Dahan , 2010)

Figure 18





Red Brick is considered as one of the local material in China. A development of a prototype courtyard house (Fig.19) in China by Atelier Zhanglei creatively makes use of the local material (Fig. 20) and the local workers during construction. Based on the information from HomeDesignHome.com, due to this building using local material and local worker, it has also reduced the budget of the project a lot.
Figure 19
Figure 20
4.3 Suggestion of How to Make This Alternative Outstanding
Promoting using local material merely for the sake of staying true material can save the environment, will  not impressed the public to appreciate this concept in this new era. Based on the Appendix IV, Pie Chart vi, 36% responders put the main consideration on form and shape of the building, and 25% of responders emphasize on the discovery new material or technology of the building. Thus, instead of focusing on the origin beauty of the characteristic of wood and the natural jointing, architect and designer can break through the conventional wooden building with conceptualize form and shape of the building.
McBride Charles Ryan’s work in Melbourne, Letter Box House (Fig. 21) shows the creativity of how the architect breaks through the conservative wooden building. Contrasting to the raked timber wall that stretches from the letterbox to become the westerly verandah, the remainder of the house appears as a simple modernist expression akin to many of the houses in the region. (Ryan, 2011) Using merely wood, without any finishing, yet, Letter Box House still showing the dynamic with its cut edges and the play of the wood panel arrangement and the grains. (Fig. 22)
Figure 21
Figure 22

Friday, February 18, 2011

Dissertation: 5.0 Conclusion

5.1 Summary

In brief, staying true to material in architecture field can lessen our resources wastage, as hazardous emission from paint and wallpaper wastage can be avoided without using it. Besides, in the life span wise, treatment for bare walls have the substantial benefit compare to extra finishing like painting, wall covering, or plastering. It also par with the trend that people worship returning to the nature, exposing raw material just like bare skin without heavy make-up.
Staying true to material is studied that is more environmental friendly and saving cost, however this is a thirties modernist concept, therefore, a few ways to make sure this concept is still catching up with current trend is raised. The methods include, concrete architecture can make the concrete craftsmanship prominence; put more endeavor for masonry ornamentation for brick building and discovery more on the feature aesthetic of wooden architecture.  In addition, regardless of any kinds of architectures which expose the raw material, all types of architecture must concern about the building program, as most of the people emphasize the function of the architecture. 
Truth to material always linked to exposing raw material in architecture field, perhaps, for environmental wise, people who admiring the local raw material will be more helpful to our earth. Since the transportation and processing is reduced, emission of green house gases is reduces too. Most of the vernaculars buildings are staying true to local material, and using local material need a breakthrough. Since form and shape of architecture is also one of the main considerations of public; architect or designer who ambitious to bring the concept- truth to material in architecture field up to trend can consider about the construction method of raw material, as it is infinity with conceptual ideas.

5.2 Evaluation

Less demand and less creation of architecture finishing do not equal to a backward in architecture field is proven with some case studies in previous chapter.  Therefore, staying true to material is able to supplant the commercial architecture finishing for the sake of environmental friendly yet still catching up with the current trend.
However, most of the case studies are not focus on residential architecture.  One of the reasons may cause by most of the residential buildings have completed with plastering and painting, and owners have not much choice for their building finishing. And developers do not dare to take risk giving the owner with bare wall as this is not popular. Therefore, designed architectures like themed retails, show room, studio or etc, should take role to promote the concept of truth to material, also discovery and advocate the aesthetic value of architecture exposing the raw material. Once the public appreciates the aesthetic and understands the advantages of staying true to material, and then the developer can be true to material with ease. This is the consensus in between architect and public should be reach.

5.3 Future Work

Most of the architecture finishing products labeled themselves as environmental friendly product, and mislead the public as if they are responsible to the environment with using those so called goes green products. Besides architect and designer, publisher, especially design magazine should encourage staying true to material is rather practical than using goes green finishing for the sake of helping our environment.  Last but not least, to be true to building material,  besides caring our environment, as a designer in this generation should think beyond thirties modernist;
Design within the box and think out of the box.

D: References

K.I Pengurusan Holdings Sdn Bhd. (2011). Rumah Perlis - Long Roofed House. Retrieved February 2, 2011, from Taman Mini Malaysia & Asean:
 http://tamanmini.com.my/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=160&Itemid=163

Canadian Wood Council. (n.d.). Retrieved from Case Studies of Outstanding Wood Buildings: http://www.cwc.ca/NR/rdonlyres/7B7F3EF1-B2DB-461C-8EEE774B27870E5E/0/OutstandingWoodBuildings_e.pdf

CHILVERS, I. (2003, January). truth to material(s). Retrieved Nov 24, 2010, from The Concise Oxford Dictionary of Art and Artists:
 http://www.encyclopedia.com/doc/1O3-truthtomaterials.html

Cook, J. (1987, Autumn). Postindustrial Regionalist Architecture. Journal of Architectural Education (1984-) , 41, pp. 62-64.
Ferreira, M. L. (2009). Blue Ocean Strategy - Synopsis of Kim and Mauborgne's Book. Retrieved November 4, 2010, from Scribd:
 http://www.scribd.com/doc/15440864/Blue-Ocean-Strategy-Synopsis

Gecco. (2008). Wallpaper & the Environment. Retrieved November 22, 2010, from Gecco Interior: http://www.geccointeriors.co.uk/index.php/eco-guide-wallpaper

Goodrich Global Pte Ltd. (2011). Goodrich Global. Retrieved January 4, 2011, from Product FAQs (Wallcovering):
http://www.goodrichglobal.com/dl/wallcovering_faq.pdf

Hammond, M. (2008, November 28). Marc Koehler comes up with an innovative solution for a small space. Retrieved January 2, 2011, from World Architecture News.com: http://www.worldarchitecturenews.com/index.php?fuseaction=wanappln.projectview&upload_id=10776

Harvey. (2007, November 19). Architecture in Osaka- The Chirch of the Light. Retrieved January 19, 2011, from JapanNewbie. com:
http://www.japannewbie.com/2007/11/19/architecture-in-osaka-the-church-of-the-light/

Jennifer. (2010, January 7). Share. Retrieved January 3, 2011, from Calfinder Nationwide Remodelers: http://www.calfinder.com/blog/siding/house-of-sticks-the-incredible-all-hardwood-home-design/

L&M Construction Chemical, Inc. (2011). Do you dare to go bare? Retrieved January 2, 2011, from L&M Construction Chemical, Inc:
http://www.lmcc.com/concrete_news/0410/dare_to_go_bare.asp

Minimalist Brick House Design with Unique Look. (2010, February 9). Retrieved February 2, 2010, from Home Design Home.com:
http://www.homedesignhome.com/minimalist-brick-house-design-with-unique-look/

Minimalist Brick House Design with Unique Look. (2010, February 9). Retrieved January 2, 2011, from Home Design Home.com:
http://www.homedesignhome.com/minimalist-brick-house-design-with-unique-look/

Morby, S. J. (2006). Constructing Concrete as an Art Form. In B. Cross, & J. Finke, 2006 Structural Engineering and Public Safety (pp. pp. 1-7). America: American Society of Civil Engineers.
Nodvin, S. C. (2010, July 14). Carbon Footprint. Retrieved December 23, 2010, from The Encyclopedia of Earth:
http://www.eoearth.org/article/Carbon_footprint

Paintings, A. D. (2010). Arcy Art Original Oil Painting Art Dictionary. Retrieved Nov 24, 2010, from Art Dictionary of Arcy Art Original Oil Paintings :
http://www.arcyart.com/ad-truth-to-materials.htm

Rimbun Dahan . (2010, December 8). Family Dipterocarpaceae. Retrieved January 2, 2011, from Rambun Dahan:
http://www.rimbundahan.org/environment/plant_lists/dipterocarpaceae/

Ryan, M. C. (2011). Letterbox House. Retrieved January 2, 2011, from e-architect:
 http://www.e-architect.co.uk/melbourne/letterbox_house.htm

Silloway, K. (2004). galinsky . Retrieved November 28, 2010, from Church of Light: http://www.galinsky.com/buildings/churchoflight/index.htm

Thompson, J. S. (2002, January). Art Talk.com . Retrieved Nov 24, 2010, from Artist Profile: http://www.arttalk.com/archives/vol-12/artv1203-3.htm

Wijnen, B. v. (2011). Malaysian House. Retrieved February 1, 2011, from Malasiasite: http://www.malaysiasite.nl/malayhouse.htm

Wikipedia. (2010, November 15). Truth to materials. Retrieved November 26, 2010, from Wikipedia: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Truth_to_materials

Zeballos, C. (2010, January 9). TADAO ANDO: GARDEN OF FINE ARTS. Retrieved November 27, 2010, from My Architectural Moleskine:
http://architecturalmoleskine.blogspot.com/2010/01/tadao-ando-garden-of-fine-arts.html

Zimmer, D. (2001-2008). Paint and Environmental Considerations. Retrieved November 20, 2010, from Paint Quality Institute:
http://www.paintquality.co.uk/health/solvent_envir_risk.htm

Zimmer, D. (2009). Water-based vs. Solvent-based. Retrieved November 20, 2010, from Paint Quality Institute:
 http://www.paintquality.com/going-green/paint-types/water-solvent.html

D: Appendix I

Article related to paint and environment considerations from
Zimmer, D. (2001-2008). Paint and Environmental Considerations. Retrieved November 20, 2010, from Paint Quality Institute:
http://www.paintquality.co.uk/health/solvent_envir_risk.htm

Paint and Environmental Considerations

There are two basic types of paint to choose from: water-based paints often referred to as acrylic emulsions, and solvent-based paints. High-quality water-based paints offer not just an excellent all-round performance profile; they are also a good choice from an environmental perspective. Solvent-based paints, the more traditional type of paint, require users to exercise a degree of caution to avoid potential damage to the environment
Solvent-based paints are a source of potentially hazardous emissions called Volatile Organic Compounds (VOCs), a family of substances that easily evaporate into the air to form invisible vapours.
When evaporating, the solvents contained in paint emit VOCs into the atmosphere. VOCs react with oxygen in the presence of sunlight to form ozone – "bad" ozone.

It is important to distinguish between "good" ozone and "bad" ozone.
"Good" ozone occurs naturally in the stratosphere about 10-35 kilometers above the ground, which protects the surface of the earth from harmful ultraviolet rays and acts to protect plants, animals and humans from its various harmful effects.
"Bad" ozone occurs at ground level, forms through the chemical reaction between VOCs, oxygen and sunlight, and is an irritant for the mucous membranes. It can also cause nose, eye, and throat irritations; and can lead to shortness of breath, coughing, and asthmatic symptoms.
This "bad" lower-atmosphere ozone can also damage vegetation – plants, trees, bushes – and such impacts negatively on those dependent on nature for their livelihood. This ozone also has a corrosive effect on certain man-made materials: for example, it accelerates the deterioration and fading of certain paints.
A further major consequence of VOC emissions is global warming – VOCs play a significant role with respect to the creation of the greenhouse effect. Further, some chemically very stable VOCs participate in the destruction of the stratospheric ozone layer (the "good ozone"): this is the famous hole in the ozone layer.
According to a study of the C.E.P.E (Conseil Europeens de L’Industrie des Peintures, des Encres, d’Imprimerie et des Couleurs d’Art) roughly 4 to 5 % of total VOC emissions are linked to the manufacture and application of paints and varnishes – with solvent-based paints playing a major role.



D: Appendix II

Architecture Finishing Quotation from Mr. Keith Tam Tong Keat, renovation contractor of Infiniti Home Ideas

D: Appendix III

Quotation for different finishing partially provided by Ms. Alyson Khoo Rui Jing

 

* The treatment for bare concrete, is generally refer to the initial installed to chemically harden and density a new concrete floor, the cost is approximately $0.30 (RM 0.91)/ ft², is normally a single, one-time cost for the total 30-year life cycle of the floor. (L&M Construction Chemical, Inc, 2011).
RM0.91/ ft² = RM 10.05/ m²



*
In refer to the advertisement above taken from the official web site of Goodrich Global Pte ltd; one roll of wallpaper is assumed that cost $166.33 ($499/3rolls), with installation service included.
Standard wallpaper sizes are 520mm (1ft 9 inches) x 10.05m (33ft) (interior-design-it-yourself.com, 2011)

0.52m x 10.05m = 5.226 m² of wallpaper cost $166.33 (RM 395.51)
Therefore, cost of wallpaper is RM75.65/m² (RM6.85/ ft²)





D: Appendix IV (a)

Survey Question and Result

This appendix is a summary finding of public’s perception staying true to material in architecture field, based on 60 public drawn among Facebook friends and friend’s friends from different sector.
Total Started Survey: 60
Total Completed Survey: 52 (86.7%)
Period: 10 February - 13 February 2011

Survey Question :

D: Appendix IV (b)


Survey Result Analysis
Survey Question 4, “Other”:
1. i feel tat can bring out another feeling.. kinda special n creative i thk..
2. Represents yourself, i.e. the way your house office looks and the interior designs and decorations can show what type of person are u, your financial status, your profession, your character and so on. It gives either good or bad impression to people especially when people are doing business with you.
3. conceptual
4. It is something like what we called "less is more".. Using as minimum materials as possible to come out with minimalist design.
5. paying respect for the original aesthetic to the material
6. Its not really a concept, hoay phing. Its a way of life. Materials such as brick wall should be allowed to breathe. Covering it with paint/wallpaper blocks its porous capacity.
7.it is one of the way to respect the raw materials...
it sort of an education aspect...
it will give the truth feeling or sense of intimate contact with those materials...
it create sort of harmony environment in or outside the structure...

Survey Question 5, “Why”:
1. totally dono what's mean by "truth to material" concept
2. its saves cost on beautifying the building more
3. it depends on the material and whether it is embodied in energy, or Eco-friendly at all!
4. im not very sure about tat just feel lik will save some source
maybe because dont need use those stuff to hide their natura
5. Because it is considered as environmental-friendly material.
6. sustainable
7. actually, i would say mayb. is depends on the materials. truth to materials does not tell me tat it is using 'go green' materials. like man-made or industrial materials will caused the waste of energy use. to help the environment, it will definitely better if using nature resources.
8. Definitely, you're allowing the walls to breathe. And you dont waste money on paints so much. Most paint are not no eco.
9. Example:
some paint is not sustainable or even harmful to human..
the plastering work is reduce, this mean time and cost saving (due to labour fee)..
especially for timber work, it is a beauty if the texture and raw colour is highlighted...
10. Absolutely, where we live may shaped what we are

Survey Question 6, “ Other or why you focus on that consideration”
1.form and shape is the first thing that can put an impression on us at first sight.after that material and color and functionality. and at the end, the best result comes out when we mix all the above together.
2.and also the interior designs and decorations. And if the building has some high tech stuffs like all the electrical things in the house can be controlled by one remote using bluetooth,or iphone, it will be cool as well.
3.Material choice should come first, then only the form that showcases the bests of the chosen material. Remember Rujia's thesis, she wrote about the Swiss Pavilion, Hanover Expo 2000. That was brilliant.
4. I think architecture is a piece of artwork that include all those aspects..
An architecture is failed for me, if it is only consider one of them..
(your answer force me to choose one of that)